There is no such thing as “Russian borsch”

There is no such thing as “Russian borsch”

There is no such thing as “Russian borsch” just as there is no “English bouillabaisse” or “German onion soup.”Borsch is not a recipe. It is a UNIVERSE. A Ukrainian Universe.

Sure, some Russians—provided they aren’t completely hopeless, clumsy fuckups (and let’s admit it, such people exist, despite 99% of statistics suggesting otherwise)—might be able to RECREATE a decent, classic, standard borsch. This assumes they follow a written recipe precisely, have access to good ingredients (which are becoming increasingly scarce for them), and possess proper kitchen tools (for which they’ll soon face total “import substitution”—meaning, they simply won’t have any at all.

But does this make the borsch “Russian”? Of course not!

Personally, having capable hands, GOOD kitchen tools, and ACCESS to QUALITY ingredients, I could—for instance—recreate a Marseillais bouillabaisse, French onion soup, Boston chowder, Thai Tom Yum, a Czech roasted pork knuckle, Levantine shakshuka, Indian raita, Mexican chili con carne, and so on.

Does this make the chowder Ukrainian?

Does it make me a Marseillais, a Frenchman, a Thai, an Arab, or a Czech (oops!)? Well, obviously—fuck no.

An average person from Marseille, France, Thailand, or the Arab world would make these dishes BETTER than I could, because it’s *theirs*.

Russians base their claims to borsch on a single mention of the plant “borshchevik” in the 16th-century *Domostroy*. Moreover, the *Domostroy* began to be written in Novgorod—which is “Russian” my ass—and it mentions only the *herb* itself, not the *dish* (and borsch, as you well know, is a rather *complex* dish; mentioning just *one* ingredient is by no means enough to identify it).

Borsch is an ENTIRE UNIVERSE

“There were about six kinds of borsch”

—from Kotliarevsky’s *Eneida*, at the funeral feast for Anchises.

SIXKINDS OF BORSCHT—all different.

Well, let’s set a task for some “competent Russian moron”™: try cooking SIX different borschs!

And let’s set that same task for an average Ukrainian housewife!

  • Easy:– classic, with beef, *without* beans
  • – classic, with pork ribs *and* beans
  • – Galician-style, with “heaps of beets” and thickened with sour cream/flour (*pidbyvanyy*)
  • – Poltava-style, with *halushky* (dumplings)
  • – Lenten (meatless), with crucian carp
  • – with chicken (“A black cloud rolls in—looks like rain [“дощ”]. Mother chops up a rooster—looks like borsch [“борщ”]…”)
  • – Chernihiv-style—with *no beets at all*
  • – made with beet greens and *kvas* (fermented grain liquid)

…green… orange… red… white…with sour cream… *without* sour cream… onions diced or sliced ​​into half-moons… cabbage added after the potatoes, or last of all… fresh tomatoes or tomato paste… should you sprinkle the beets with lemon juice or not… fifty grams [of vodka] or half a liter??

For crying out loud—what are we even talking about here??? What the fuck do the Russians have to do with this? Where the hell did they even come from? Nobody invited them—get lost, you northern barbarians™!

THIS IS OUR UNIVERSE!

Where, at the very center of existence, shines the Constellation of BORSCH!…now I’m craving borscht……and a fifty-gram shot

Anton Dvorzhak, 2026